Pre-workout and energy supplement tubs beside a cup of black coffee

Supplements That Can Make Anxiety Worse

If you search for supplements that worsen anxiety, you will find two kinds of lists. The first kind blames everything — every herb, every vitamin, every powder — with no evidence at all. The second kind says nothing is risky, which is just as wrong. The truth is narrower, and it is better documented than most people realise. A small handful of ingredients have actually been tested in people and shown to raise anxiety or trigger panic. This page covers only those — the ones with real studies behind the warning — and says plainly where the evidence runs out.

No affiliate links on this page — just the papers.

The Myth I Hear Most: “Natural Means It Can’t Hurt”

The idea that a supplement cannot make anxiety worse because it comes from a plant is the single most expensive belief in this market. Caffeine comes from a plant. Yohimbine comes from tree bark. Both of them have been used by researchers for decades as reliable ways to provoke anxiety in the lab — not because the researchers were careless, but because the effect is that consistent. When scientists want to study a panic attack, they do not wait for one to happen naturally. They give a volunteer caffeine or yohimbine and watch what follows.

That is the standard this page uses. An ingredient earns a place here only if researchers have given it to people under controlled conditions and measured more anxiety, or if a pooled analysis of those studies says the same thing. Everything else — the long lists of “avoid this herb” with no citation — I left out.

Caffeine: The Best-Documented Culprit

Caffeine is the one to start with, because the evidence is the strongest and the dose is the easiest to get wrong. A 2022 meta-analysis by Klevebrant and Frick pooled ten blinded, placebo-controlled challenge studies in people with panic disorder. Across the nine studies that measured panic attacks, 51.1% of 237 patients had a panic attack after caffeine — and none had one after placebo. In the six studies that also tested healthy controls, panic followed caffeine in 53.9% of patients and only 1.7% of controls.

The doses in those studies were high: 400 to 750 mg, mostly 480 mg, which the authors describe as roughly five cups of coffee. That matters, because it means the finding is about big doses, not about your morning cup. The same review is honest about its own limits: the narrow dose range meant no proper dose-response analysis was possible, and only two of the ten studies reported anxiety data for the placebo condition. Even so, the panic finding is about as clean as this kind of research gets — a coin flip for a panic attack on caffeine, zero on placebo.

It is not only people with panic disorder. A 2024 meta-analysis in healthy people without psychiatric disorders pooled 14 studies with 546 participants and found caffeine raised anxiety overall, with a much larger effect at high doses — above 400 mg — than at low ones. And an older study from 1985 still tells the story well: Charney and colleagues gave caffeine at 10 mg per kilo of body weight to 21 patients with panic disorder and 17 healthy volunteers. The patients reported far greater increases in anxiety, nervousness, fear, palpitations, restlessness and tremor, and 71% of them said the caffeine effects felt similar to their panic attacks.

None of this means a normal amount of coffee causes anxiety in everyone. It means caffeine is a stimulant that raises arousal, and in people whose anxiety already runs hot, a big dose can tip arousal into panic. Our caffeine and anxiety guide goes through the dose curve in detail.

Yohimbine: Built to Raise Alarm

Yohimbine is the ingredient I would put second, and it is the one most people have never heard of. It comes from the bark of the yohimbe tree, it is sold for fat loss and sexual performance, and it works by blocking alpha-2 adrenergic receptors — which removes the brake on norepinephrine release. In plain language, it turns up the body’s alarm system.

Researchers have known this since the 1980s, because they used yohimbine deliberately as a panic challenge. In 1984, Charney and colleagues gave it to 20 healthy volunteers and 39 drug-free patients with agoraphobia and panic attacks. Yohimbine produced significantly greater increases in patient-rated anxiety, nervousness, palpitations, hot and cold flashes, restlessness and tremor in the patient group than in healthy volunteers, and the anxiety tracked with a rise in a norepinephrine metabolite in the blood. Four years later, Mattila and colleagues gave yohimbine at 0.8 mg per kilo to 16 healthy students in three placebo-controlled crossover trials. Even in healthy young people, yohimbine shifted mood towards feeling panicked, raised systolic blood pressure, and brought on tremor, chills and nausea. Caffeine at 10 mg per kilo in the same study left the same students only slightly panicked — yohimbine was the stronger of the two.

That is why yohimbine has no place in the routine of anyone with anxiety or panic. It is not a borderline case or a dose question. The ingredient’s core mechanism is to raise the exact signals — racing heart, tremor, a sense of alarm — that anxious people are already trying to quiet. If you see yohimbe bark or yohimbine HCl on a fat-burner or pre-workout label, and you have any history of anxiety or panic, that product is not for you.

Bitter Orange and Synephrine: Stimulant, Weaker Evidence

Bitter orange extract, sold for weight loss and energy, contains p-synephrine, a stimulant related to ephedrine. The evidence here is thinner than for caffeine or yohimbine, and I want to be straight about that. No trial I found set out to measure whether synephrine causes anxiety. What the trials do show is that it raises the physical signs of arousal.

A 2022 systematic review and meta-analysis pooled 18 placebo-controlled trials of bitter orange extract and p-synephrine. With prolonged use, systolic blood pressure rose by 6.37 mmHg and diastolic by 4.33 mmHg, and the authors concluded that synephrine tends to raise blood pressure and heart rate. Weight loss, the reason most people buy it, was not significant after prolonged treatment, and body composition did not change. So the honest picture is: measurable stimulation, no proven weight-loss payoff.

Why does that belong on an anxiety page? Because a faster heart and higher blood pressure are exactly the sensations that anxious people notice and fear — and in someone with panic disorder, those sensations can become the trigger for an attack. I am not claiming synephrine causes anxiety the way caffeine does; the trials did not test that. I am saying it is a stimulant with real cardiovascular effects and no proven benefit to offset them, which is a poor trade for anyone whose anxiety is already loud.

The Stack Problem: Pre-Workouts and Fat Burners

The worst cases I have seen are not single ingredients — they are stacks. A pre-workout or fat burner can combine caffeine, synephrine and yohimbine in one scoop, sometimes with the caffeine dose hidden inside a proprietary blend. Each ingredient on its own raises arousal; together they add up, and the label may not tell you by how much. If a product lists a “proprietary blend” with no amounts, you cannot check the dose against anything in this guide — and that, on its own, is a reason to leave it on the shelf.

The same logic applies to energy drinks. A large can plus a coffee plus a pre-workout can put you past 400 mg of caffeine before lunch without any single product looking extreme. Count the total, not the single serving. If your anxiety has crept up since you started a new energy product, the simplest test costs nothing: stop the product for two weeks and see what changes. That is not a diagnosis and it is not a trial — it is just the cheapest experiment available, and it tells you more than another supplement will.

What I Left Out, and Why

You will notice this page is short on ingredients. That is deliberate. Plenty of lists online blame herbs like ginseng, ginkgo or green tea extract for worsening anxiety, but I could not find controlled human studies showing that effect, so I did not include them. Absence of evidence is not proof of safety — it just means the claim is not proven, and I would rather leave a gap than fill it with a guess. If a new trial appears, this page should change. Until then, the list above is the list the evidence supports: caffeine at high doses, yohimbine at ordinary supplement doses, and synephrine as a stimulant with real cardiovascular effects and no proven payoff.

The Honest Bottom Line

Most supplements do not make anxiety worse. The ones that do are almost all stimulants, and the evidence is clearest for caffeine above 400 mg and for yohimbine at any normal dose. If your anxiety has worsened, look at the stimulants first — the coffee, the energy drinks, the pre-workout, the fat burner — before you buy something else to fix it. Removing the thing that is winding you up beats adding a second thing to calm you down, and it costs nothing to try.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can caffeine cause a panic attack?
At high doses, yes — in people with panic disorder. In pooled challenge studies, 51.1% of patients had a panic attack after 400–750 mg of caffeine and none did after placebo. At ordinary doses the risk is far lower, and our caffeine guide covers the dose curve.

Is yohimbine safe if I don’t have anxiety?
It still raises blood pressure and heart rate and can cause tremor, chills and nausea even in healthy volunteers. The anxiety warning is strongest for people with panic or anxiety, but it is not a gentle ingredient for anyone.

Does synephrine cause anxiety?
No trial has tested that directly. What is proven is that it raises blood pressure and heart rate with prolonged use, and that it does not produce significant weight loss. The anxiety concern is indirect — stimulation that feels like anxiety — not a tested effect.

What about green tea extract or ginseng?
I found no controlled human studies showing either one worsens anxiety, so I did not include them. That is not proof they are safe for everyone — it means the claim is unproven, and you should judge them on their own evidence.

I take a pre-workout and feel jittery. What should I do?
Check the label for caffeine, yohimbine and synephrine, add up your total daily caffeine, and try two weeks without the product. If the jitteriness fades, you have your answer. If anxiety persists or worsens, talk to a doctor — see our guide on when to see a doctor for anxiety.

Sources

This guide is general information, not medical advice, and it is not a substitute for your own doctor — especially if you take regular medication or have a health condition. If anxiety is seriously affecting your life, talk to a doctor promptly rather than trying supplements first.