Editorial Policy

Most supplement “reviews” online are sales pages wearing a lab coat: a miracle claim, a row of five stars nobody earned, and a buy button. This site exists to do the slower version — read the actual label, check the actual price, read what buyers complain about, and publish the cons alongside the pros. This page explains how that works, in the open, so you can hold us to it.

How Reviews Are Scored

Every review on this site follows the same checklist, so scores are comparable from product to product. The full method lives on our how we review page, and the short version is this: five categories, each scored from 1 to 5, combined as a weighted average. Ingredients and safety count for 25%, label transparency 20%, value for money 20%, guarantee 20%, and buying experience 15%.

As a rough guide, a 5 means research-backed ingredients at meaningful doses, a full label with every dose printed, a cost of about $1.20 a day or less, a 365-day guarantee and a smooth one-time checkout. A 3 means some of those are missing or unclear. A score rates the product and the offer as a buyer actually gets them, and anything the sales page gets wrong is reported in the review under “what to know before you buy”. A score is our editorial opinion, not a clinical result.

What Never Moves a Score

Commission rates never move a score. Whether a product pays a high commission, a low one, or none at all has no bearing on its rating, its placement, or whether it gets reviewed in the first place. The same goes for manufacturer pressure: if a company asks for a softer review or a better rating, the answer is no, and the review stays as written.

Popularity doesn’t move a score either. A bestseller with a hidden label still gets marked down for the hidden label, and a quiet product with a transparent label still gets credit for it. The checklist is the same for every product, and the score follows the checklist.

No Paid Placements

Manufacturers cannot pay for placement on this site — not for a better rating, not for a softer review, not for earlier placement in a roundup, not for a review at all. There is nothing to buy. Reviews are chosen by reader interest and researched the same way whether or not an affiliate programme exists for the product.

That also means the roundups on this site — like our best supplements for anxiety page — rank products by their review scores and the evidence behind them, not by who pays best. If a product sits at the top of a list here, it earned the spot on the label and the guarantee.

What We Don’t Claim

We don’t claim a product will work for you, and we never invent customer experiences. If we haven’t bought and tested a product, we say so — and most reviews on this site are label-and-evidence reviews, not personal trials. We don’t invent ratings, review counts or testimonials. Where a review mentions figures from a manufacturer’s own site, it says that’s where they came from.

We also don’t repeat a marketing claim as fact. Claims are compared with what the label and the available evidence support, and anything that can’t be verified is flagged as unverified rather than repeated. If a guarantee is reported differently in different sources, the review says so instead of picking the friendlier number.

Who James Carter Is

Our reviewer is James Carter — the site’s reviewer persona. He trains five days a week and reviews supplements the way he trains, by the numbers: label first, price-per-day maths second, refund fine print third, and buyer complaints before any score is set. That is the full picture, and we don’t dress it up. He is not a doctor, and nothing on this site is medical advice. We don’t invent credentials, qualifications or a biography for him beyond what our about page already says — the work should stand on the checking, not on a made-up CV.

How Products Get Chosen

Products get reviewed because readers ask about them, or because they sit in a category readers are already searching — sleep, memory, energy, and the rest. Requests arrive through our contact page and go on the review list in the order they arrive. We don’t take requests from manufacturers to review their own products, and we don’t let a manufacturer jump the queue.

Each review checks the same things: the label line by line, the price and guarantee on the manufacturer’s page at the time of writing, the sales-page claims against the label, and what real buyers complain about alongside the praise. Prices and terms are checked on the date shown on each review, and they can change after that — which is why reviews carry their check date and why our corrections policy exists.

Money and Affiliate Links

This site is reader-supported. Some links on this site are affiliate links: if you buy through them, the site may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That is how the reviews stay free to read. It never buys a better verdict — our first review criticises its own product’s label in detail, affiliate link and all. The full details are on our affiliate disclosure page, and a short version appears in the footer of every page.

No Medical Advice

Nothing on this site is medical advice. Content here is general information only, and supplements are personal decisions that belong in a conversation with your own doctor — especially if you take regular medication or have a health condition. Supplements are not medicines and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If a review ever reads like it is telling you what to take, it has failed its own policy — tell us through the contact page and we will fix it.